Note: I hope that it will be clear after the reading
that finding out how the movies were made and of subsequent fan reaction was
not something at which I arrived using my own intuition. Those have been
culled over the years from books, websites, and films. Many of which I do
not remember because I’m getting to be an old fan.
To try to make things less confusing for everyone, here
are some terms I throw out throughout these blog entres:
- ILM – Lucasfilm’s in-house visual and optical effects unit
- EU – Explanded Universe. These are tales told outside of the film through books, comic books, video games, etc. They have given just about every character in the cantina scene a proper name, species, and a backstory. Many fans consider this body to be canonical – that is, having as much value to the Star Wars saga as the movies themselves. I’m not one of them J
- Matte lines – outlines and other black marks on the outside and other part of objects created through the bluescreen process, paintings, and other visual elements.
- CG or CGI – computer generated or computer generated imaging. The source of most, if not all, of the changes controversy.
Okay, so every Star Wars fan has noticed and most certainly
has an opinion of the changes in the Star Wars.
I am certainly one of them. How
serious are these changes? Let’s
discuss, shall we?
Prequels.
It’s nice that we know have a CG Yoda, but it’s also a
little sad that the only piece of Frank Oz’s puppetry skills in this movie are
lost. But that Yoda in The Phantom Menace
looked a little like the title characters in the movie Gremlins rather than the
Yoda we saw in the original trilogy. Now
at least with the CG one there’s consistency, as he starts resembling the other
versions of himself (sounds weird, doesn’t it).
Oh, Yeah in, AOTC I guess there’s now Shmi screaming in Anakin’s
nightmares.
But we don’t care that much about what was done to the
prequels, do we? Let’s go to the movies
that have really stirred up discussion.
Especially beginning with:
A New Hope (a.k.a. just “Star Wars”)
Before we get too far into this, I have to state that I am
in no way a technical guy, and there are those who have analyzed the changes a
lot more. To go into the minutiae, I
would recommend Wookiepedia. This has all kinds of details like the timing
of the opening crawl, and keeps track of the lightsaber color changes whereas I
always lose track of them. What I’ll
deal with are some changes that I think have gotten more attention and emotional responses from fans. Well, not all of them, but most. Anyway...
Tatooine Evening
I particularly though it was a nice touch. Artoo is abducted before nightfall, and the
next day the sandcrawler they are aboard arrive at the Lars homestead. In the original it was all daylight during
the great droid hunt, then suddenly dusk when the Jawas brought their kill back
to the sandcrawler. Of course, that
destroys my memories of all those stills in daylight featuring the Jawas and Artoo,
but it’s still not enough to protest that George Lucas violated my
childhood.
Stormtroopers Go a-Hunting
OK, what was originally a rubber dewback in the backfround
in the original release now has now come to life via CGI. This is all preceded by stormtroopers
patrolling the desert sands (the new part takes place in Yuma and is merged with
the original footage shot in Tunisia).
The new sequence features a stormtrooper riding a dewback with four
stormtroopers, each moving on foot faster than the dewback, and the sand
doesn’t seem to slow them down. So: Why
bother with the lizard?
The “Krayt Dragon Call”
For the not-so-nerdy, the Krayt (the name comes from the
novelization) dragon call is what Ben (Obi-Wan) Kenobi uses to frighten the
Sandpeople (aka Tusken Raiders) away when he is first introduced. I think I recall many fan websites with
information on the various changes. But
this last one in the Blu-Ray version was way different. Why?
One possibility: the original
wail (or at least one of them) was much like the dewback, or probably was the dewback. I lose track, and don’t pay too much
attention…until the Blu-Ray. So I guess the
justification for the changes is that a creature indigenous to Tatooine is less
likely to freak out the Tuskens. Or at
least, that’s my guess. The new yell is
also a little more terrifying.
Artoo In His Hiding Place
This was an interesting change in the Blu-Ray version. It shows Artoo hidden behind a bunch of
rocks. There is, however, no way of
determining how he maneuvered in and out of it.
![]() |
| kool.cbslocal.com |
Above: before Blu-Ray changes. Below: Blu-Ray changes
How’d he get
in there?
+
+
Luke, Ma. No Wheels!
I’ll wait until you finish groaning. The scenes of the landspeeder zooming across
the desert had an obscured bottom in the theatrical version. The life-sized landspeeder had wheels that either
at times had mirrors or in the case of the Mos Eisley scenes, there was
Vaseline smeared across the bottom of the lens. This rather blurry underside
was jokingly referred to as the “force field.”
Now it’s all cleaned up and the landspeeder is…oh….floating on air…
Mos Eisley Exteriors
One thing I liked about the changes is that since…you
know…the place is called Mos Eisley SPACEPORT, you would expect to see more
ships than the Millennium Falcon. And
you’d expect it to be a little busier. And
that appears to be the case with he Special Edition. Also, there
are additional creatures and probe robots.
I wonder who the lucky ones are who have to clean up the mess. That is, from the
animals, not the robots.
And oh yes, we are SO going there…
Yup: It’s Han Shoots First…OR Is It Greedo That Shoots First?
I don’t think a change has had many fans lighting torches
and sharpening pitchforks more than this.
My initial response when seeing the Special Edition in the theater was
“Wait, something’s different about it." And boy was it. The original
scene, which I at least think I remember as well as anyone else, has Greedo
saying that he “has been looking forward to this (killing Han) for a very long
time.” Han retorts, ”Yes, Ill bet you
have.” There is a flash, and next is a clear
two-shot with Han and Greedo’s head – attached to his smoldering body- dropping
onto the table. The new version that has been there since then has Greedo
firing first, and then Han firing, and Greedo’s head – attached to his
smoldering body- dropping onto the table.
Lucas has said that Greedo always shot first.
![]() |
| quickmeme.com |
Even with that change, my initial thought to the fan outrage was, “Go back to your mother’s basement and take some REALLY deep breaths. It’s nothing to get upset about.” I just thought it really didn’t change things that much. I didn’t think it changed the plot at all.
But as I heard more of the fans’ complaints, I began to see things from their viewpoint. The plot was really not the issue. The issue was the character development of Han Solo that was not being maximized by this scene alteration. When we first meet him, he’s a smuggler. His work is illegal and he therefore risks getting caught by imperial authorities, and we have to assume imperial law enforcement is not merciful. He has to seek the protection which puts at the mercy of some very crooked characters. His work is dangerous. And here he is, out for himself until he decides over the course of the movie to be a part of something greater than himself (that’s Joseph Campbell’s explanation, which I really like and I think I’ll steal). Having Greedo shoot first takes away somewhat from his self-centered pirate character. Sure Han kills Greedo in self-defense, but shooting first means that he’s not taking any chances and let the other guy get a shot off. It makes him the rugged loner in a kill-or-be-killed galaxy. Kind of like a western.
In a bonus Blu-Ray disc, the original dialogue in the scene filmed in England (before it was re-done with Greedo's moving ears and mouth in California) had Greedo being there for no other reason than to kill Han. And he was really, really enthusiastic about doing it. Regardless if Greedo seems to enjoy his job as a hired assassin, we might expect him to at least be able to aim more accurately at near point-blank range. That shot was not only wasted, it was sad.
So why was the scene re-done, anyway?
One fan theory – or rumor - goes (at least I think it’s a fan theory) is
that Lucas didn’t realized he had kids and didn’t want them to see the hero
murder someone in cold blood (or something like that).
The Jabba Scene
This I think is related to the Greedo Scene. I was excited to see the Jabba scene, because
it was one of those scenes – like the Biggs scenes (to be explained later) - that
I knew always existed and that I finally would see, even though I know full
well it was re-touched. Other fans did
not agree. One of the minor ones is that
it wasn't the same immobile slug in Return of the Jedi
I say big deal. So you don’t get
your sophisticated puppet. Why can’t we
just say the guy ate too many of those frogs or whatever they were between then
and Return of the Jedi. Being a crime boss is lonely, and you don’t
get to experience real meaningful friendships.
Maybe he just ate a lot of comfort food for his loneliness. That’s plausible, isn’t it?
![]() |
| slaveleia.wikia.com |
OM NOM NOM NOM
*sigh* *sniff*
But where the fans seem to have their strongest point is
that it disrupted the pacing of the movie and was therefore unnecessary. Let’s look at that view. George Lucas filmed the scene with actor
Declan Mulholland. His original
intention was either to matte come kind of slug head on him or to somehow
replace him with a stop-motion animation character.
![]() |
| rottentomatoes.com On the right, a decidedly non-CGI Jabba |
When Lucas realized he was running out of
time and he wasn’t going to finish the scene, he transferred most of Jabba’s
dialogue to Greedo. Han, while pulling
his gun from the holster under the table in his confrontation with Greedo, says
the line “Even I get boarded sometimes.
Do you think I had a choice?” If
you compare that with the Jabba scene, you realize that line was actually dubbed
into the Greedo confrontation from that scene.
So what do we get from the Jabba scene now that it’s in? Well, we get that:
·
What Jabba looks like, sort of.
·
Han is not intimidated by Jabba. There are many examples of this:
o
He tells him angrily to not send one of his
“twerps”
o
He steps on Jabba’s tail, which steamed off some
fans. But this was Lucas’ solution to a
problem the animators were having because Han went around the human Jabba, but
would be running through the CGI
Jabba’s tail. But his expression did go
from an “ouch” in the 1997 Special Edition to a why-you-I’m-gonna-smack-you
expression in the Blu-Ray
o
Jabba says “For an extra 20%”, Han counters, “15,
don’t push it”
So what else do we have? Anyone? Oh yeah, the insertion of Boba Fett. Yeah, anyway…
Takeoff From Mos Eisley
Okay, CGI Millennium Falcon taking off from the docking
bay. The circular hole structure kind of
sets things up for Episode II when the Naboo cruiser lands.
![]() |
| legopunk.com |
Above: An
awesome Lego artists’ rendering of the Docking Bay






No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are moderated for this blog.